|
The Historicity of
The Urantia Book
The following story is the product
of years of investigation and many hours of discussion with those associated
with the origin of the Urantia Papers. It includes a personal knowledge and
friendship with key people in the Urantia movement over the past thirty-eight
years.
During this period I served pastorates in the
United
Church of
Christ and joined the faculty of Indiana Institute of Technology, acting as
head of the Department of Psychology, chair of the Division of Liberal Arts,
and President. I have been especially careful to maintain academic
objectivity and exercise critical evaluation of both The Urantia Book and the
Urantia movement. The essential elements of the following narration have been
cross-validated many times by numerous people who had first-hand experience
in the events associated with the origin of The Urantia Book.
The Chicago Story
Dr. William S. Sadler (1875-1969),
physician, surgeon, psychiatrist, professor, and author of forty-two books,
was a man of unusual abilities. He was a popular lecturer on Chautauqua
platforms and promoted modern medicine and mental health issues through
talks, magazine articles, and books. As a result of this effective advocacy,
he and his wife, Dr. Lena Sadler, were frequently asked by friends and
acquaintances to host an informal group where medical and social issues could
be discussed. Accordingly, the Sadlers started a Sunday afternoon tea in the
mid 1920's, which became known as"The Forum," where such topics
were examined and sometimes debated. In time the Forum came to be composed of
professional people: doctors, lawyers, dentists, ministers, and teachers,
along with individuals from all walks of life -- housewives, secretaries,
farmers, and common laborers.
One Sunday a Forum member asked
Dr. Sadler what he thought about a psychic medium who was drawing large
crowds in one of the local theaters. Dr. Sadler replied that he had
investigated many such psychics and found they were either dishonest frauds
or sincere but self-deceived people whose subconscious mind activity led them
to believe they were getting knowledge from the spirit world."Then,"
he added,"there is one that I haven't figured out yet." They, of
course, wanted to know about this person, later called"the contact
personality," and Dr. Sadler shared some of the information gathered
since 1911.
For a number of years he and a
small group of associates, called"the contact commission," had the
opportunity of testing and verifying the content of unusual forms of distant
communication. They were trained and familiarized with the technique of
communication and information imparted by the alleged extra-planetary
personalities, later known as"the revelators." Through such a
sharing of information, the agenda of the Forum was virtually taken over by
the revelators.
Around this time, a personality
who claimed to be a student visitor to the planet challenged the contact
commission saying,"If you people realized what a high spiritual source
you were associated with, you would stop making these puerile investigations
to detect fraud and ask some significant questions about the nature of
reality and the universe." Dr. Sadler took this message to the Forum and
suggested that they take up the challenge by writing questions which could be
taken to the revelators. They agreed to do so, and the many questions submitted
were organized by Dr. Sadler. The first question presented was,"Is there
a God; and, if so, what is he like?" In response they received five
papers which the revelators requested be read to the Forum and kept in Dr.
Sadler's office safe.
Soon after the first Urantia
Papers were presented, the revelators requested that they form a closed
group. Each member of the Forum was asked to sign a pledge which read:"We
acknowledge our pledge of secrecy, renewing our promise not to discuss the
Urantia revelations or their subject matter with anyone save active Forum
members, and to take no notes of such matter as it is read or discussed at
the Forum meetings, or make copies or notes of what we have personally
read." Membership tickets were issued and the charter membership
numbered thirty. From time to time new members were received into the Forum
after being interviewed by its officers and signing the pledge of secrecy.
During the Forum's existence its membership rose to a total of 486. Members
of the Forum were permitted to come to 533 Diversey Parkway and read the papers, but they were never taken
from the building.
The original papers were
handwritten. Handwriting experts agreed that it was not the writing of the
human individual whose superconscious mind was used in some way in the
materialization of the papers. They were requested to have these original
papers typed and carefully checked by the members of the contact commission.
Whenever the original papers were typed and checked, the originals in the
locked safe disappeared.
Occasionally, after papers were
read and placed in the office safe, they disappeared. When the contact
commission inquired about this disappearance, very little explanation was
given beyond the fact that it was their decision to withdraw the paper. Other
papers were altered after being read to the Forum. For instance, one of the
papers stated that the apostle Nathaniel had"a good sense of humor for a
Jew." The members of the Forum chuckled at this comment. The next time
they obtained this paper from the safe, they discovered the phrase"for a
Jew" was deleted. The assumption was that they were required to read
these papers to the Forum so that these higher beings could observe human
reaction to the material presented. In this manner the papers composing The
Urantia Book were received in the mid 1930's.
In 1939 members of the Forum were
asked for volunteers who would be willing to meet on Wednesday evenings to
seriously and systematically study the Urantia Papers. Seventy persons
expressed their desire to join this class, and they became known as"The
Seventy." The seventy were trained through papers and by directives from
the revelators and by Forum leaders up to the time of the publication of The
Urantia Book. Special emphasis was placed on the evolutionary nature of the
acceptance of new truth and the danger of using mass media and revolutionary
methods in presenting the message of the Urantia Papers to our contemporary
culture.
When permission to publish the
Urantia Papers was given, the revelators stated that they regarded The
Urantia Book as a feature of the progressive evolution of human society. The
book belongs, they said, to the era immediately following the ideological
struggle in which they saw our planet involved. Early publication was granted
so that leaders and teachers might be trained and translations of the book
could be published in other languages. Various instructions were given for
the publication of the book including the procurement of an international
copyright.
In preparation for the publication
of The Urantia Book, the Urantia Foundation was established by a Declaration
of Trust under the laws of the State of Illinois on January 11, 1950. The Foundation is managed by
a five member Board of Trustees who are appointed for life terms. The
trustees' duties and responsibilities are defined in the Declaration of
Trust. Among the most important of these are the publication of The Urantia
Book and preserving its text inviolate in perpetuity.
When the Foundation made an appeal
to the Forum members for funds to cover the first printing of 10,000 copies,
the response was immediate. The cost of the first edition was around $75,000.
The book is printed at the Crawfordsville, Indiana plant of R. R. Donnelly and Sons Company, and was
published by the Urantia Foundation on October 12, 1955.
A French translation of The Urantia Book was published in 1962.
Finnish and Spanish translations were published in the spring of 1993. Work
continues on the Dutch and Russian translations, with translations into
Korean, German, Swedish, Hungarian, and Italian on the horizon.
Study Groups and Societies
Members of the Forum recognized
that some sort of fraternal organization was sure to grow out of the
teachings of The Urantia Book. Accordingly they organized the Urantia
Brotherhood on January
2, 1955, and the
Urantia Brotherhood Corporation, which acts as the legal and fiscal agent of
the Brotherhood, on October
21, 1955, under the
laws of the State of Illinois. In December, 1959, the Internal Revenue Service
of the United States ruled that the Urantia Foundation, the Urantia
Brotherhood, and the Urantia Brotherhood Corporation were tax-exempt,
not-for-profit organizations.
The organizational building blocks of the Urantia Brotherhood are local
Societies which emerge from mature study groups, and they function with great
autonomy. In 1989, as the result of a dispute over democratic control of the
Brotherhood, the Brotherhood severed organic connection with the Urantia
Foundation and changed its name to the Fifth Epochal Fellowship, now better
known as The Fellowship for students and readers of The Urantia Book, with
offices at 529 Wrightwood, Chicago, IL 60614. The Urantia Foundation,with
offices at 533 Diversey
Parkway, Chicago, IL 60614, is sponsoring a new fraternal organization
entitled The International Urantia Association. These fraternal organizations
are primarily interested in the spiritual stimulation and growth of people of
all faiths and religions. Future Development
Both the Urantia Foundation and
The Fellowship have refrained from using mass media, believing that person to
person contact and slow evolutionary growth is the most effective long term
policy for introducing people to The Urantia Book. It is rather amazing that
in a time when reporters are examining all kinds of cults and new religious
movements, The Urantia Book has received little general publicity. The
academic world is just beginning to discover its existence. In 1983, Dr.
Jacques Rheaume at the University of Ottawa wrote a doctoral thesis on the topic"An
Analysis of a Revealed Text: The Urantia Book" (Analyse d'un Texte Revele:
The Urantia Book). In 1985, there was an American
Academy of
Religion Consultation on the theme"The Urantia Book in Religious
Studies."
The Urantia Book is one of the
most promising sources of creative thought in philosophy, religion, and
culture in our contemporary world. It has extremely broad ramifications. The
authors' overarching grasp of the dynamics of civilization and culture shed wisdom
in almost every area of human endeavor. Although we are confident the church
will one day view The Urantia Book as an authentic and enlarged source of
spiritual truth, it will only gain such recognition through critical
evaluation by laypersons, ministers, and theologians.
Personal
Account of Finding The Urantia Book Circa 1960 (Copied from hand
written paper 4/8/97)
Like most people who are
introduced to the Urantia Book and told that it is written by celestial
beings and materialized on our planet, I was highly, if not completely,
skeptical of such claim when a lawyer friend presented me with a copy of the
Urantia Book in the early spring of 1956. Both to humor my good friend, who,
to the best of my knowledge, had always carried an unusual reputation for
sound judgment as a lawyer and judge, and to show my appreciation for his
fifteen dollar gift, I decided, after skimming the contents of the book, to
read a couple of chapters in the section on the Life and Teachings of Jesus
and thus be able to talk knowingly about the book the next time I saw the
Judge.
As I read, I searched in vain for
the esoteric mysticism which I was sure must pervade the book. Instead, I was
increasingly intrigued by the spiritual insight, philosophic coherence, and
scientific relevancy of its message. A couple of months later when I finished
the last of its 2097 pages, I knew the Urantia Book was one of the most
significant books of our age.
Then I went to the Judge with the
persistent question so many people since that time have addressed to me,
"Now, I want to know who really did write this book! Who are the people
responsible for its origin?" My central activity for the next several
years involving many, many trips to Chicago and elsewhere was in gathering first hand evidence
which might shed light on an accurate answer to this question.
Here, in condensed form, is the
story of the historicity of the Urantia Book. Every aspect of the story was
checked by first hand, critical observation of those persons directly involved
in the story. I am personally convinced of the absolute integrity of the
personalities involved.
Much to my surprise, I discovered
that Dr. William S. Sadler was the leader of a small group of people in
Chicago who received and eventually were responsible for publishing the
Urantia Papers. Dr. Sadler is one of the most highly respected psychiatrists
in the country and is in some circles called the "Father of American
Psychiatry." For many years he taught in the post-graduate Medical
School at Chicago
University
and for almost thirty years was a lecturer in Pastoral Counseling at McCormic
Theological Seminary. Dr. Sadler's wife, Dr. Lena Sadler, also a physician,
shared in the leadership of this group.
Dr. Sadler, as a physician, in
1911 first came in contact with the individual who was used in some way in
the production of the Urantia Papers. Being especially skeptical of esoteric
and spiritualistic phenomena, he did a great deal of research examining
mediumistic personalities and came to the conclusion that all such persons
were either fraudulent or self-deceived by subconscious psychic
abnormalities. These findings he reported in a book entitled, The Mind at
Mischief, published by Funk and Wagnalls in 1929. In this book he calls
attention to one case which does not fit this pattern. [Pages 382-384 of the
Appendix].
During the period between 1911 and
the mid-twenties, Dr. Sadler had an opportunity to observe, examine, and test
the contact personality in various ways which helped to establish his confidence
in the reliability of the information received through the contact
personality. He became thoroughly convinced that the "subject" who
was later associated with the Urantia Papers was in no way similar to any
other well-known type of psychic performance--such as automatic writing,
channeling, clairvoyance, telepathy, trances, spirit mediumship, or multiple
personality.
Both Dr. William and Dr. Lena
Sadler were in great demand as speakers and Dr. William Sadler was a prolific
writer during most of his medical career. As a result of this public contact
they built an extensive circle of friends who were interested in discussing
medical, psychological, and religious questions. To meet this demand the
Sadlers opened their home to a Sunday afternoon discussion group. This group
became known as "The Forum," and consisted of all types of
people--doctors, lawyers, ministers, teachers, housewives, secretaries, and
common laborers.
Eventually one of the members of
the Forum asked Dr. Sadler what he thought about mediums. Sadler replied that
his investigations convinced him that they were either frauds or
self-deceived people, but there was one case he hadn't figured out yet. The
group asked him to tell about this unusual case, and in this manner the
Forum's central interest was eventually shifted to the Urantia Papers.
About this time, they were told at
a contact session that if they realized the high quality of their source of
communication they would stop their mundane investigations and start asking
some real questions about the nature of things in the universe. Accordingly,
Dr. Sadler asked members of the Forum to hand in questions regarding things
they would like to know.
Among the first questions asked
was, "Is there a God, and if so, what is he like?" In answer to
this question five papers were received. These papers were then read and
discussed at the Forum meetings. This procedure continued as they went
through the questions submitted by the Forum.
Early in the proceedings the
superhuman personalities supervising the contact sessions had selected a
small group from the Forum known as the "Contact Commission" who
were charged with the responsibilities of safe-guarding the papers, putting
them in typewritten form, and acting as a liaison committee between the
"revelators" and the Forum. The original manuscripts were in
handwritten form. After typewritten copies were made and checked by the
contact commission, the original papers in the locked safe in Dr. Sadler's
office disappeared.
About this time, instructions were
received from the revelators to form a closed group. From time to time new
members were admitted after being interviewed by the officers of the Forum.
Every member of the closed group were requested to sign pledges which read:
"We acknowledge our pledge of secrecy, renewing our promise not to
discuss the Urantia revelations or their subject matter with anyone save
active Forum members, and to take no notes of such matter as it is read or
discussed at the Forum sessions, or make copies or notes of what we
personally read."
When questions presented by the
Forum were answered there were fifty-seven papers. The revelators then
suggested that since the Forum, as a result of the first fifty-seven papers,
could now ask more intelligent questions, they would undertake to enlarge the
revelation in accordance with a new list of questions. This procedure was
followed over the next few years and by 1934 resulted in the 196 papers now
found in The Urantia Book.
At this point mention should be
made of the type of people who were members of the Forum. I expected to find
people with glints in their eyes, mystics, and individuals with messianic
inclinations. I found just the opposite. The original Forum was made up of
intelligent, well-balanced people who exhibit to a marked degree the critical
scientific attitude. During this period Dr. Sadler worked with the magician,
Thurston, and the noted explorer, Sir Hubert Wilkins, trying to diagnose this
unusual situation. Thurston had previously helped Sadler in exploring
fraudulent mediums.
They finally came to the
conclusion that they were dealing with some type of genuine phenomena and
that, in any case, the contact individual was simply incapable of producing
the quality of the papers received. Thurston became so fascinated with the
content of the papers that he stored his show for a whole year while he made
a detailed study of the Urantia Papers. Wilkins took a three month leave of
absence from his work to study the papers. Both men before they died had arrived
at the conclusion that the papers were, in all probability, that which they
claimed to be.
In 1939 the leaders of the Forum
in consultation with the revelators decided that it was time to form a class
to seriously and systematically study the Urantia Papers. The project was
presented to the Forum and seventy persons volunteer to enter upon this
study. This class became known as "The Seventy" and communications
from the revelators were addressed to the seventy. The seventy were trained
up to the time of the publication of the book, with special emphasis placed
on the evolutionary nature of the acceptance of new truth and the danger of
using broadcast, indiscriminate, or revolutionary methods in presenting the
message of the Urantia Papers.
Restrictions of secrecy were
gradually released and in 1955 they were given permission to publish the
book. They were told that the book does not belong to the present era but to
the times which will follow the present ideological struggle. Nevertheless,
an early publication of the book was being given so that leaders and teachers
could be trained and so that men of means may be found to provide
translations into other languages. Although a wealthy member of the Forum was
willing to furnish the money required to publish the first edition ($75,000),
and Dr. Lena Sadler had gathered $25,000 for this purpose before her death in
1939, the revelators requested that members of the Forum should be asked for
voluntary contributions to finance the publication.
Before the book was published, the
revelators asked members of the contact commission and others who had
information, to take an oath promising not to reveal the identify of the
individual whose Thought Adjuster was used in some way in the transmission of
the Urantia Papers, nor to say anything they might know about the method of
the materialization of the papers. They were given three major reasons for
making this request. The revelators acknowledged that this request would be a
stumbling block in the early years after the publication of the book, but
said that it was wise to have no St. Peter or St. Paul connected with the publication a thousand years
hence. Secondly, they wished to discourage anything of a miraculous nature
being associated with the papers. And finally, they recognized that the book
would not be received because of any unusual phenomena connected with its
origin, but only by those who recognized the spiritual quality of the message
of the book.
Dr. Sadler told me that he
probably knows more about the nature of the materialization of the papers
than anyone else but that he really does not know how it was done. If he were
allowed to tell me everything he knew, he assured me, for every point at
which I now had a question, I would have two questions to take its
place.
Dr. Sadler conducted many tests in
the course of the reception of the papers. For instance, the revelators asked
that the questions be put in written form and when the papers arrived the questions
always disappeared. So he began placing the questions in his lock box in a
downtown bank. They still disappeared but he was eventually told that they
wished he would cease such puerile activities because it caused them extra
work.
One of the members of the contact
commission told me the best hypothesis he had concerning the production of
the papers had three points of activity: (1) the celestial being who was the
author of the paper, (2) the mind of the human subject, (3) a midwayer
(supermortal beings who are very close to material beings and who can engage
in physical activities) somewhere taking the dictation. "I knew where
point number two was, but we never knew anything about point one and point
three." He acknowledged that this hypothesis could be incorrect. Dr.
Sadler told me that just about all that is known about the origin of the
Urantia Papers can be found at various places in the Urantia Book.
As the Forum continued reading the
Urantia Papers, Dr. Sadler saw that his wife, Lena, and many others were quite impressed with their
content. And so one Sunday he made a speech reminding them that they were a
critical discussion group but that he observed some were being influenced by
the papers. The general response which he received was to the effect:
"We aren't being uncritical. Regardless of the authorship of the papers,
they make more sense than anything in this field that we have ever
read."
I asked Sadler when and why he
finally accepted the papers for what they claim to be. He replied that his
professional pride was at stake and so he maintained a critical professional
attitude until most of the papers were received. His decision to throw in his
intellectual towel came," he said, when they received the paper on the
twelve apostles. "I'm a psychiatrist," he said, "and I think I
know my business. But this paper gave me an inferiority complex. Even if I
had a staff of psychiatrists and years to work on it, I don't think I could
prepare a paper of this quality. You almost have to have access to the
interior of the human mind to write such a paper. So I finally decided to
admit that we were dealing with superior knowledge."
To prepare for the publication of
the Urantia Book the Urantia Foundation was organized and chartered as a
nonprofit organization in the State of Illinois. The Urantia Foundation is the publisher, under
international copyright, of the Urantia Book.
Knowing that some sort of
organization would grow out of the teachings of the Urantia Book, it was
decided wise to organize the Urantia Brotherhood as such a fraternal
organization and possibly prevent extremists from starting such an
organization. The Urantia Brotherhood is not an attempt to start a new church
but simply a group of people interested in the teachings of the Urantia
Book.
This, in brief, is what I found in
my research. And while I am personally convinced in the absolute integrity of
the people connected with the origin of the Urantia Book, I wish to emphasize
that the fact of their genuineness, proves nothing about the quality or merit
of the Urantia Book. This can be judged only by the content of the book
itself.
I consider the question or origin and authorship purely a secondary
consideration. I am interested in the Urantia Book only because the insights
and relevancy of its message is superior to any philosophic-religious point
of view with which I am acquainted. But I should also like to emphasize that
the book cannot be evaluated until you get its entire philosophical-religious
picture. |